Jul11
Can your Credit Card Company Really Dictate What you Can’t Buy?
Can a credit card company dictate what you purchase on your credit card? In the case of American Express, it seems they can.
American Express recently banned purchases of medical marijuana with its credit cards, and the resulting debate has brought the idea of credit card companies and the authority they should carry when consumers make purchases deemed questionable back into the spotlight.
Some of the purchases banned by some credit card companies include: gambling chips, donations to controversial non-profit organizations, medical marijuana and, in some cases, pornography.
Most credit card companies say that they are simply protecting themselves against legal liability, but consumer groups say that they are simply infringing on consumers’ rights and shouldn’t play the morality card.
John M. Simpson, of the consumer group Consumer Watchdog, says: “It seems to me that credit card companies are imposing their moral values on the world.”
It appears that, among the industry’s biggest companies, that American Express is the most conservative of them all, as it has banned medical marijuana in all 16 states that have legalized it. They have also banned online pornography.
Inconsistencies in Credit Card Rules
Some critics, however, note that there is a considerable amount of inconsistencies in these rules. For example, some cardholders don’t allow its credit card customers to charge gambling chips, but they can use the casino’s ATM to get cash advances at casinos.
A MasterCard spokesman has adopted a number of policies to “combat illegal or brand-damaging behavior.” American Express states that it “abides by federal law and prohibits transaction where the risk of dispute is unusually high.”
Adhering to Federal Law, or Making Moral Judgments?
In addition, American Express bans online pornography sales with its credit cards because they want to fight sales of child pornography. As such, they ban all pornography sales as an “additional safeguard.” Medical marijuana is also prohibited because the company says it is “adhering to federal law.” MasterCard and Visa are expected to follow suit.
American Express has banned online pornography purchases since 2000 because they considered it to be a “risk-based decision” because they had to deal with a number of disputed transactions prior to that date. They consider their decision to be based on risk alone; that it is “not a moral judgment.”